Bea Arthur Was Living a Double Light for 36 Years, and NO ONE Knew Until Now

Bea Arthur Was Living a Double Light for 36 Years, and NO ONE Knew Until Now

Bea Arthur could silence a room with one look or draw laughter with a single line, but the woman behind the formidable stage presence remained fiercely private throughout her life. Behind the famous deep voice and raised eyebrow was Bernice Frankel, a Brooklyn-born woman whose path to television stardom included a secret military career, two marriages, and a generosity she hid even from her own son. Born on May 13, 1922, in Brooklyn to Rebecca and Philip Frankel, Bea grew up in a Jewish household with two sisters before the family relocated to Cambridge, Maryland, in 1933 to run a women’s clothing shop. Standing nearly 5 feet 9 inches by age 12, she was sent to an all-girls boarding school in Pennsylvania at 16 after developing a dangerous blood clotting condition, followed by a year at Blackstone College in Virginia.

Thumbnail

Her own dream at the time was to become a small blonde movie star like Ida Lupino, an ambition far removed from the commanding presence she would later build on stage and screen. In 1943, with World War II underway, Bernice Frankel enlisted in the United States Marine Corps Women’s Reserve, one of the first groups of female members. After basic training, she worked as a typist at Marine headquarters in Washington, D. C.

, before transferring to Motor Transport School at Camp Lejeune. From 1944 to 1945, she served at Cherry Point as a truck driver and dispatcher. Her military records described her as “officious,” “over aggressive,” and “argumentative,” while also noting careful taste and strong work habits. She rose to staff sergeant and was honorably discharged in September 1945.

During her service, she met fellow Marine Robert Alan Arthur, whom she married while still in uniform, taking his surname permanently even after the marriage ended. After leaving the Marines, Bea first trained as a medical laboratory technician before realizing that path was not for her. In 1947, she returned to New York and studied drama under Erwin Piscator and Lee Strasberg at The New School. She later credited three figures with shaping her style: Sid Caesar taught her the outrageous, Strasberg taught her reality, and Lotte Lenya taught her economy.

Her early career moved slowly through off-Broadway productions until she married actor Gene Saks in 1950, a relationship that would last 28 years and produce two adopted sons, Matthew and Daniel. Her stage breakthrough came in 1964 when she originated the role of Yentl the Matchmaker in the Broadway premiere of Fiddler on the Roof. Two years later, she auditioned for the title role in Mame but lost it to Angela Lansbury, who became a close friend. Instead, Bea took the supporting role of Vera Charles and won the 1966 Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Musical.

Composer Jerry Herman later said there was no one else like her, noting she could make people laugh during rehearsals with only a look or a word. Television came calling in 1971 when Norman Lear invited Bea to guest star on All in the Family as Maude Findlay, Edith Bunker’s outspoken cousin. The clash with Archie Bunker worked instantly, and CBS executives reportedly responded, “Who is that girl? Let’s give her her own series.

” Maude debuted in September 1972 and ran for 141 episodes through 1978, tackling subjects other sitcoms avoided: the Vietnam War, divorce, menopause, drug use, mental illness, women’s rights, gay rights, spousal abuse, and politics. The most controversial moment came with the two-part episode “Maude’s Dilemma,” aired around Thanksgiving 1972, in which Maude decides to have an abortion. The subject was explosive on American television at the time, with abortion still illegal in many states and Roe v. Wade roughly two months away.

Some CBS affiliates refused to air the episode, replacing it with older programs or holiday specials. An estimated 65 million viewers eventually saw the story during its original run or summer reruns. Bea won the Emmy for outstanding lead actress in a comedy series in 1977, but by the late 1970s, she felt Maude had run its course. She left during the sixth season after Norman Lear tried to refresh the series by having her character elected to Congress.

That same year, 1978, her marriage to Gene Saks ended after 28 years. She never entered another publicly known serious relationship, instead preferring a quiet home life. Adrienne Barbeau, who worked with her on Maude for six seasons, described her as a homebody who cared about her sons, her dog, and her cooking. Several smaller projects followed, including the 1978 Star Wars Holiday Special, Mel Brooks’ History of the World Part 1, and the short-lived 1983 sitcom Amanda’s.

Then came the decision that would create her most enduring role. After an NBC special featured a sketch called Miami Nice about older women in Florida, network executive Warren Littlefield pushed to develop the idea. Susan Harris wrote a pilot that aged the characters into their 60s. Estelle Getty, Rue McClanahan, and Betty White were cast, with McClanahan and White switching roles after a director suggested it.

NBC executives had concerns about Bea’s likability ratings and asked casting director Joel Thurm to find alternatives, but after Elaine Stritch auditioned without winning people over, the search returned to Bea. She initially hesitated, having already worked with McClanahan on Maude, but changed her mind once she learned the roles had been switched. The Golden Girls premiered in 1985 and became a massive success, remaining in the top 10 for six of its seven seasons. Bea later said of her character Dorothy Zbornak, “I’m not playing a role.

I’m being myself, whatever the hell that is. ” Yet the warmth viewers saw in the living room was not always matched behind the scenes. Bea’s Broadway-trained focus on the work clashed with Betty White’s television-born comfort with breaking the fourth wall. White would talk to the crowd between takes, and Bea considered that unprofessional.

They were friends in the early years, even traveling to work together, but the mood changed over time. White won an Emmy for the series in 1986 before Bea did, and Rue McClanahan later recalled that Bea reacted angrily. Bea won her own Emmy two years later. People who worked on the series offered conflicting accounts of the tension.

Writer Barry Fanaro remembered hearing the two women yelling backstage one week, though he said it was the only time an argument reached that level. Stagehands once slipped funny nude pictures of themselves into a prop calendar, and Bea’s huge laugh helped break the tension. Script supervisor Isabel O’Meara recalled seeing Bea and Betty walking arm-in-arm after tapings, complicating the feud narrative. McClanahan described Bea in softer terms, calling her giving and loving and saying she was actually quiet, timid, and gentle away from work.

The writers repeatedly made jokes about Dorothy’s looks, height, body, and supposedly masculine appearance, which cut closer for Bea because they were based on features she actually had. She had spoken openly about being typecast, saying, “Look, I’m 5 ft 9. I have a deep voice, and I have a way with a line. What can I do about it?

” She also once joked, “Let’s be honest. Nobody ever asked me to play Juliet. ”

Bea left The Golden Girls after the seventh season in 1992, ending the original series. Her son Matthew said she had wanted to leave a year earlier but stayed because the others asked her to return.

She believed long-running shows eventually lose something in the writing, production, or overall magic. The remaining three stars continued with The Golden Palace, which lasted only one season. Her decision mirrored her exit from Maude, a preference for walking away when she felt a show had run its course. Afterward, she returned to the stage work that mattered deeply to her.

She toured with a one-woman show known at different times as An Evening with Bea Arthur and And Then There’s Bea, made her Metropolitan Opera debut in 1994 as the Duchess of Crackenthorpe in La Fille du Régiment, and earned a Tony nomination in 2002 for Bea Arthur on Broadway: Just Between Friends. She appeared on Malcolm in the Middle as Dewey’s strict babysitter, voiced the Femputer on Futurama, and played Larry David’s mother on Curb Your Enthusiasm. In 2005, she appeared at the Comedy Central Roast of Pamela Anderson and read sexually explicit passages from Anderson’s book in the same deadpan style that made her famous. Late in life, Bea became involved with the Ali Forney Center in New York, which helps homeless LGBTQ+ young people.

She learned about the center’s financial trouble in 2005 through her friend Rae Klausner. Already ill with cancer, she flew from California to New York and revived her one-woman show for a benefit that raised about $40,000. She explained her support directly, saying, “These kids at the Ali Forney Center are literally dumped by their families because they are lesbian, gay, or transgender. This organization really is saving lives.

” She continued helping the center without making a public show of what she gave, keeping the scale of that support private. A heavy smoker, Bea developed lung cancer and died peacefully at her Los Angeles home on April 25, 2009, at age 86, with family nearby. She was cremated and her ashes were scattered at sea. Broadway dimmed its lights in her memory three days later.

A month after her death, friends including Angela Lansbury, Norman Lear, Rosie O’Donnell, and Rue McClanahan gathered for a public tribute in Manhattan. Then came a final surprise even Matthew had not expected: Bea had left $300,000 to the Ali Forney Center in her will without telling him. A year after her death, her official military file became public, making her 2001 denial that she had ever served even more striking.

In 2017, the organization opened the Bea Arthur Residence, an 18-bed Manhattan home for homeless LGBTQ+ youth, in her name.