John Denver Was Living a Double Life For 28 Years, Now We Finally Know Why

John Denver Was Living a Double Life For 28 Years, Now We Finally Know Why

John Denver spent 28 years carefully separating the wholesome image the world saw on stage from a private life that told a very different story. Behind the gentle voice that produced anthems like “Rocky Mountain High” and “Take Me Home, Country Roads” was a man navigating legal trouble, a collapsing marriage, and personal struggles that would only fully come into focus after his death. Born John Deutschendorf Jr. , Denver grew up in a strict military household.

Thumbnail

His father’s Air Force career meant constant moves, forcing young John to repeatedly start over in new towns and schools. The hardest part, he would later admit, was his father’s difficulty showing affection. The rigid, controlled environment gradually pushed the oldest son inward. By his junior year of high school, he stole his father’s car and drove to California, where he had relatives and a growing interest in music.

His father tracked him down and brought him home, but the rebellion signaled what was to come. In 1963, Denver dropped out of college and relocated to Los Angeles for good. He booked his own gigs and built a reputation locally before joining the folk group The New Christy Minstrels. His birth name proved impractical for a performer—too long for a marquee—and the group suggested he adopt the name Denver, taken from a song they were working on.

The change stuck. Two years later, Denver joined the Chad Mitchell Trio, a folk group known for satirical songs targeting conservative politics. It was an environment far removed from the wholesome image he would later cultivate, but the group introduced him to something more important than another musical job: Annie Martell. Denver noticed her in the audience at a University of Minnesota concert in the mid-1960s.

The two didn’t speak that night, but roughly three weeks later, Martell received a letter from him asking if they could meet. Within about a year, they were married, both still in their early twenties. Denver’s ambitions soon outgrew the trio. He wanted to write his own songs and put together an album of original material in 1967, but no record label would release it.

He mailed copies to family and friends as Christmas gifts instead. The album arrived during a complicated moment in American history. In 1968, while Denver’s younger brother was deployed to Vietnam, Denver was performing at a peace concert—a sign that his life was moving in a direction his family might not have expected. The breakthrough came almost by chance.

“Leaving on a Jet Plane,” one of the songs from his self-produced album, landed in front of the right people and climbed to the top of the charts by the end of the decade. Still, Denver and his producer Milt Oaken spent months convincing record labels to take a chance on him. The industry was dominated by rock music, and Denver’s clean-cut folk sound didn’t match what executives were chasing. RCA Records finally signed him in 1969 and released “Rhymes and Reasons,” but the real work was just beginning.

Denver organized his own Midwest tour, put up his own posters, and arranged his own radio appearances. It worked—he built a loyal audience rather than just a quick hit. In 1971, “Take Me Home, Country Roads” exploded, introducing Denver to an audience far beyond the folk scene. “Rocky Mountain High” followed and became another major hit, but it came with controversy.

Some critics believed the title was a hidden reference to drug use, and several major radio stations refused to play it. The controversy couldn’t stop the song from becoming one of his signature works. The tension over where Denver fit in the music industry became impossible to ignore at the 1975 Country Music Association Awards. Denver won Entertainer of the Year, but presenter Charlie Rich pulled out a lighter and set the envelope on fire on live television.

Many interpreted the moment as a protest—to some traditional country figures, Denver simply didn’t look or sound like a country artist. Behind the stage, his biggest battle was in his marriage. After one particularly heated argument in the mid-1970s, Denver wrote “Annie’s Song” in roughly 10 minutes while riding a ski lift. The deeply romantic song became one of his biggest hits, but it couldn’t fix their underlying problems.

The couple had struggled to have children and eventually adopted a son and daughter in the mid-1970s. Fame had created cracks in the marriage that children couldn’t repair. By 1979, Martell openly discussed how difficult Denver’s celebrity had become, admitting it left her deeply insecure. Denver acknowledged his relentless schedule kept him constantly on the road.

At one point, he disappeared to Switzerland for nearly a week, though an emotional phone call from Annie brought him home. Denver’s personal struggles were quietly consuming him. Critics called him “the Mickey Mouse of rock,” and the constant attacks took a toll on his confidence. He turned to EST, a controversial self-help program popular in the 1970s.

But no seminar could prepare him for what was coming. In his autobiography, Denver later opened up about darker parts of his marriage, admitting he had been unfaithful and that the relationship had sometimes become physically aggressive. In 1982, Martell filed for divorce. When the two met to divide their belongings, the situation reportedly became frightening.

Denver allegedly became aggressive toward Martell, and according to reports, he even tried to choke her. Then came an incident that sounded almost unbelievable: Denver arrived at the property division meeting carrying a chainsaw. He didn’t use it against Martell, but he reportedly used it to cut their marital bed in half so they could each have a piece. The same year, Denver’s father died unexpectedly.

Their relationship had been difficult during his childhood, but they had grown much closer later on—his father even taught him to fly, giving them a bond that had been missing. Before the year was finished, Denver cut ties with his longtime manager Jerry Weintraub, who reportedly responded by calling Denver a Nazi—a shocking accusation for a man with a long public history of promoting peace and humanitarian work. In 1985, some of the biggest names in music gathered to record “We Are the World,” a charity project for famine relief in Africa. Given his humanitarian history, Denver expected to be included.

He wasn’t. By then, his commercial popularity had begun to decline, and some participants reportedly believed adding Denver would weaken the song’s impact. Willie Nelson reportedly joked that if a bomb hit the building during recording, Denver would suddenly be number one again. The room laughed, including major stars like Michael Jackson and Kenny Rogers.

Denver later admitted being left out broke his heart. Denver began pursuing another lifelong passion: space exploration. He had always been fascinated by NASA and began training in 1985 with the hope of traveling into space. In January 1986, the Challenger disaster killed all seven astronauts aboard and effectively ended his dream.

He wrote “Flying for Me” as a tribute to the astronauts. His career on Earth was also struggling. In 1986, RCA Records dropped him, a decision reportedly tied more to changes in company leadership than to his talent. During a trip to Australia, Denver met actress and singer Cassandra Delaney, who reportedly didn’t realize he was a major international star at first.

They married in 1988, but the relationship burned hot and fast—they separated in 1991 and finalized their divorce in 1993. After the divorce, Denver’s personal life began unraveling in public. In 1993, police stopped him for driving under the influence, and he received probation. Less than a year later, he crashed his Porsche into a tree in Aspen while intoxicated again, violating his probation.

The case ended with a deadlocked jury, but the Federal Aviation Administration suspended his flying privileges and required him to demonstrate long-term sobriety before he could legally fly again. In October 1997, Denver took off alone in a small experimental aircraft he had recently purchased. He was an experienced aviator who had been flying for years, but he had owned this particular plane for only about two weeks, and it had unusual modifications. The fuel selector handle had been placed behind his right shoulder, requiring him to unbuckle his seat belt and twist around to reach it.

Denver had reportedly raised concerns about the location with a technician shortly before taking off. Before heading out over Monterey Bay, he had already spent significant fuel practicing takeoffs and landings, meaning he would need to switch fuel tanks at some point during the flight. The plane crashed into Monterey Bay, California, killing Denver on impact. While his previous DUI arrests prompted immediate questions about alcohol or drugs, toxicology testing found no alcohol or drugs in his system.

The National Transportation Safety Board determined that Denver had told air traffic control he planned to remain airborne for another hour, then likely reached behind himself to switch fuel tanks. As he twisted around, his body may have pushed against the aircraft’s controls, sending the plane into a steep maneuver he couldn’t recover from. His limited familiarity with the aircraft made it more difficult to regain control. The crash was ultimately attributed to pilot error.

Authorities used his fingerprints to confirm his identity. A permanent memorial marks the crash site today, where fans continue to remember the singer. After his death, another side of Denver slowly came into view. He had always been open about his love of nature, flying, music, and painting, but photography was a passion he had largely kept to himself.

The public didn’t fully discover it until 2014, when an exhibition of his previously unseen photographs opened. It was his songs that ultimately became his lasting legacy. “Take Me Home, Country Roads” and “Rocky Mountain High” were both officially adopted as state songs for West Virginia and Colorado respectively. Denver remains the only musical artist whose songs have been officially adopted as state songs by more than one state.

Every time those songs play, his voice still brings people back to the mountains, the open road, and a simpler America he spent his life trying to capture.